Quick Verdict
Choose Kraken — Never hacked, available in more states, higher fees but much better security track record and stability.
Consider Binance.US only if you're in an available state, want 0% maker / 0.02% taker fees, and are comfortable with the regulatory uncertainty.
⚠️ Binance.US Regulatory Situation
Binance.US has faced SEC lawsuits and suspended USD deposits/withdrawals temporarily in 2023. The situation has stabilized but regulatory uncertainty remains. Kraken also faced SEC action but handled it more smoothly. Factor this into your decision.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | Kraken | Binance.US | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trading Fees | 0.40-0.80% | 0-0.02% | Binance.US |
| BTC Trading Fee | 0.40-0.80% | 0-0.02% | Binance.US |
| Security Record | Never hacked | Parent hacked 2019 | Kraken |
| US Availability | 48 states | ~40 states | Kraken |
| Cryptocurrencies | 200+ | 150+ | Kraken |
| Regulatory Status | Stable | Uncertain | Kraken |
| Staking (US) | Halted | Available | Binance.US |
| Margin Trading | 5x | Not available | Kraken |
| Mobile App Rating | 4.5★ | 3.5★ | Kraken |
Fee Breakdown
Kraken Fees
Binance.US Fees
Cost on $10,000 Trade
Kraken: $40-80
Binance.US: $0-2 (any spot pair)
Binance.US wins on fees—if you can use it and trust the platform.
State Availability
Kraken Unavailable In:
New York, Maine
Available in 48 states
Binance.US Unavailable In:
New York, Texas, Vermont, Hawaii, Louisiana, Idaho, and more
Available in ~40 states
Who Should Use Which?
Choose Kraken If:
- ✓ Security is your top priority
- ✓ You want margin trading (5x)
- ✓ You need futures trading
- ✓ You want a reliable, stable platform
- ✓ You're in a state Binance.US doesn't serve
Consider Binance.US If:
- ✓ Lowest fees are your priority
- ✓ You mostly use limit orders (0% maker fees)
- ✓ You want US-based staking
- ✓ You're comfortable with regulatory risk
- ✓ You're in an available state
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Binance.US the same as Binance?
No. Binance.US is a separate US-regulated entity, though it shares technology and branding with Binance Global. Binance Global is not available to US residents—using VPNs to access it violates their ToS and potentially US law.
Will Binance.US survive the SEC lawsuit?
Unknown. They've stabilized operations but the lawsuit continues. If you use Binance.US, keep only trading amounts there—don't store significant holdings long-term until regulatory clarity emerges.
Why did Kraken stop US staking?
SEC enforcement action in early 2023. Kraken settled for $30M and discontinued US staking rather than fight. If you need exchange staking, Coinbase and Binance.US still offer it.
The Bottom Line
Kraken is the safer choice—never hacked, more states, better app, and stable regulatory standing. You pay more (0.40% vs 0% maker) for peace of mind.
Binance.US has the lowest fees (0% maker!) but carries regulatory uncertainty. Good for fee-conscious traders who understand the risks and are in available states.
Compare All Exchanges