Best Crypto Exchange in New York 2025
NY has the strictest crypto regulations in America. Here are your only 3 fully-licensed options—and why most exchanges won't touch the Empire State.
⚡ Quick Verdict
Gemini is the best choice for most NY residents. Founded in New York, it's specifically designed for the state's strict regulations, offers full functionality including transfers, and has an excellent security track record. Coinbase is a close second with more coins. Both hold full BitLicenses.
What is the NY BitLicense?
The BitLicense Explained
The BitLicense is a business license for cryptocurrency activities in New York, issued by the New York Department of Financial Services (NYDFS). Introduced in 2015, it's the strictest regulatory framework for crypto in the United States.
Any company wanting to offer crypto services to NY residents must either hold a BitLicense or operate under a different NYDFS charter (like a limited purpose trust company).
Why Most Exchanges Skip New York
The BitLicense requires extensive compliance infrastructure including:
- Capital requirements: Significant financial reserves to protect customers
- Cybersecurity standards: Regular security audits and incident reporting
- Consumer protection: Strict KYC/AML procedures and disclosure requirements
- Application cost: Reportedly $100,000+ just to apply, with no guarantee of approval
- Ongoing compliance: Extensive reporting and regulatory oversight
The Result: Most exchanges simply block NY users rather than navigate this regulatory maze. Popular platforms like Kraken, Binance.US, and KuCoin are completely unavailable in New York.
Your 3 Fully-Licensed Options
Only three major exchanges hold a full NYDFS BitLicense and offer comprehensive crypto services to New York residents:
| Exchange | Maker Fee | Taker Fee | Coins | Transfers | Staking |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 🥇 Gemini | 0.20% | 0.40% | 70+ | ✓ Full | ✓ Yes |
| 🥈 Coinbase | 0.40% | 0.60% | 250+ | ✓ Full | ✓ Yes |
| 🥉 Bitstamp | 0.30% | 0.40% | 80+ | ✓ Full | ✗ No |
🥇 #1 Gemini — Best Overall for NY
Gemini was founded in New York City by the Winklevoss twins specifically with New York regulations in mind. If any exchange understands NY compliance, it's Gemini. They operate as a New York trust company, giving them regulatory credibility beyond even the BitLicense.
Key Features for NY Users
- Full functionality: Everything works in NY—trading, transfers, staking, credit card
- SOC 2 Type 2 certified: One of few exchanges with this security certification
- Insurance: Operates "Nakamoto, Ltd." captive insurance for cold storage assets
- ActiveTrader: Pro interface with 0.20% maker / 0.40% taker fees
- Gemini Credit Card: Up to 3% back in crypto rewards
- 70+ cryptocurrencies: Solid selection of major assets
Fee Breakdown
Why Gemini for NY: Founded in NYC, designed for NY regulations from day one. The company's entire identity is built around regulatory compliance and security—exactly what NY's strict framework demands.
🥈 #2 Coinbase — Best Selection for NY
Coinbase is the largest US crypto exchange and holds a full NY BitLicense. While slightly more expensive than Gemini, it offers the widest coin selection available to NY residents—over 250 cryptocurrencies.
Key Features for NY Users
- 250+ cryptocurrencies: By far the most coins available in NY
- NASDAQ listed: Public company with regulatory transparency
- Coinbase Advanced: Pro trading with 0.40% maker / 0.60% taker fees
- Coinbase One: $30/month subscription eliminates trading fees (up to $10K/month)
- Learn & Earn: Free crypto for completing educational modules
- Staking available: Earn rewards on ETH, SOL, and other assets
Fee Breakdown
Why Coinbase for NY: If you want access to more altcoins or prefer a household-name brand, Coinbase delivers. The wider coin selection (250+ vs 70+) is the main reason to choose Coinbase over Gemini in NY.
🥉 #3 Bitstamp — Budget Option for NY
Bitstamp is the world's oldest active crypto exchange (founded 2011) and holds a NY BitLicense. Now owned by Robinhood, it offers a no-frills trading experience with competitive fees—though with fewer features than Gemini or Coinbase.
Key Features for NY Users
- Oldest exchange: 13+ years of operational history
- Competitive fees: 0.30% maker / 0.40% taker for standard users
- Low minimum volume tiers: Good rates even for small traders
- Simple interface: Straightforward, no-nonsense platform
- ~80 cryptocurrencies: Major assets covered
- Full transfers: Move crypto freely to hardware wallets
Key Limitation
No Staking: Unlike Gemini and Coinbase, Bitstamp does not offer staking rewards for US customers. If you want to earn yield on your holdings, you'll need one of the other options.
Why Bitstamp for NY: If you're a straightforward buy-and-hold investor who doesn't need staking or 250+ coins, Bitstamp's lower fees (vs. Coinbase) and proven track record make it a solid choice.
Exchanges with Limited NY Functionality
Some platforms operate in NY under limited charters that restrict functionality:
⚠️ Robinhood (Limited)
Robinhood offers crypto trading in New York but with a critical limitation: NY users cannot transfer crypto in or out. You can only buy, sell, and hold within Robinhood. This means:
- No sending crypto to a hardware wallet
- No moving to another exchange
- No receiving crypto from others
- Your crypto is trapped on Robinhood until you sell
For true crypto ownership in NY, use Gemini, Coinbase, or Bitstamp instead.
Exchanges NOT Available in New York
Due to BitLicense requirements, these popular exchanges explicitly block New York residents:
| Exchange | Why Blocked | Alternative |
|---|---|---|
| Kraken | No BitLicense (compliance cost) | Use Gemini (similar security focus) |
| Binance.US | No BitLicense | Use Coinbase (more coins) |
| KuCoin | Not available to US at all | Use Coinbase for altcoins |
| Crypto.com | Limited NY presence | Use Gemini Credit Card instead |
| Bybit | Not available to US | Use Coinbase Advanced |
| OKX | Not available to US | Use Coinbase Advanced |
| MEXC | Not available to US | Use Coinbase (for coin variety) |
| Gate.io | Not available to US | Use Coinbase |
Warning: Some NY residents attempt to use VPNs to access restricted exchanges. This violates both exchange terms of service and potentially state law. If detected, your funds may be frozen. Don't risk it—use the licensed options.
NY Exchange Comparison: Which Is Best for You?
| Priority | Best Choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Security-focused | Gemini | SOC 2 certified, captive insurance, NY trust company |
| Most coins | Coinbase | 250+ cryptocurrencies vs. 70-80 on alternatives |
| Lowest fees | Gemini | 0.20% maker (ActiveTrader) beats Coinbase's 0.40% |
| Staking rewards | Coinbase | More staking options, both work well |
| Beginners | Coinbase | Best app, Learn & Earn, most recognizable brand |
| Active traders | Gemini | Lower fees on ActiveTrader platform |
| Simplest option | Bitstamp | No-frills, straightforward trading |
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is Kraken not available in New York?
Kraken has chosen not to obtain a NY BitLicense due to the high compliance costs and regulatory burden. The company has determined it's not economically viable to serve NY users under these requirements. This is a business decision, not a reflection on Kraken's legitimacy.
Can I use a VPN to access blocked exchanges?
Technically possible, but strongly discouraged. This violates exchange terms of service and potentially NY law. If detected, your funds may be frozen indefinitely. The risk isn't worth it when legitimate options like Gemini and Coinbase exist.
What's the cheapest way to buy Bitcoin in NY?
Use Gemini's ActiveTrader platform with limit orders (0.20% maker fee). For $1,000 in Bitcoin, you'd pay just $2 in fees. Coinbase Advanced is slightly more expensive at 0.40% ($4).
Can I transfer crypto to a hardware wallet from NY exchanges?
Yes, fully. Gemini, Coinbase, and Bitstamp all allow unrestricted crypto withdrawals to external wallets. Only Robinhood restricts transfers for NY users.
Is staking available in New York?
Yes, both Gemini and Coinbase offer staking in NY. Bitstamp does not. Note that Coinbase staking is restricted in some states (CA, MD, NJ, WI) but NY is currently supported.
Will more exchanges get BitLicenses?
It's possible but unlikely to be rapid. The application process is lengthy and expensive. Kraken and other major exchanges have explicitly decided the NY market isn't worth the compliance investment under current regulations.
Our Recommendation for NY Residents
Start with Gemini. As a New York-based company built from the ground up for NY regulations, Gemini understands what NY residents need. The lower fees (0.20% vs 0.40%), excellent security, and full functionality make it the best overall choice.
Add Coinbase if you want more coins. If Gemini's 70+ coins aren't enough, open a Coinbase account for access to 250+ cryptocurrencies. Many NY crypto users have accounts on both platforms.
Consider Bitstamp for simple, low-cost trading if you don't need staking and prefer a straightforward interface.
Compare All Exchanges
See detailed comparisons of Gemini, Coinbase, Bitstamp, and more in our full exchange comparison tool.
Compare Exchanges →